|
|
Asia-Pacific
Letters from Tokyo
USA Is Looking at Plan Colombia in Order to Tackle Afghanistan
By Lee Jay Walker Tokyo Correspondent
 | Navy Admiral Mike Mullen, chairman of the U.S. Joint Chiefs of Staff | The United States is clearly worried by the crisis in Afghanistan and now a new policy is being viewed in order to tackle the growing insurgency. Therefore, the Navy Admiral Mike Mullen, chairman of the U.S. Joint Chiefs of Staff, indicated that Plan Colombia may be a new approach to the ongoing crisis in Afghanistan. However, would Plan Colombia change the current situation in Afghanistan and how successful is Plan Colombia anyway? Before focusing on this new approach which is being touted in important circles in Washington, it is vital to state the major differences between Colombia and Afghanistan. After all, do both nations share the same common problems and history? I would clearly argue that both situations are very different and Plan Colombia may merely lead to yet another failed policy. For how do you equate The Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC) with the radical Sunni Islamic insurgency in Afghanistan? Surely it must be obvious that both movements use different tactics with regards to military objectives and political desires.FARC is merely interested in installing a Marxist-Leninist government and this movement is a lot older than the Sunni Islamic Taliban and Al Qaeda threat in Afghanistan. Also, insurgents in Afghanistan want to turn this naiton into an Islamic state which will be governed via Islamic Sharia Law.Then if we focus on military tactics it becomes clear that FARC and radical Sunni Islamists in Afghanistan are very different. After all, suicide bombings and countless splinter groups within the Islamic insurgency in Afghanistan is very chaotic, however, FARC is much more military based and centralized and the leadership is clear. Yet many insurgency fighters in Afghanistan are in charge of themselves or based in very small groups and you clearly do not have any major centralized fighting machine. Instead, you have sporadic and chaotic attacks which causes major carnage but often this is done by a very small number of people and then they either melt away or if a suicide bomber, then clearly they die on the battlefield.However, Admiral Mullen and other senior members have touted the need to look at Plan Colombia and possibly use aspects of this policy in order to tackle the growing insurgency in Afghanistan and Pakistan. Admiral Mullen stated " ... that I think many of us from all over the world can learn from what has happened with respect to the very successful developments of Plan Colombia. As in all plans, there are parts of it that would be very applicable in other parts of the world and specifically to Afghanistan and there would be other parts that would not apply at all." Admiral Mullen further continued by linking both insurgencies because he stated " ... the counter-insurgency approach, the providing security for the people, the need for governance upon which the people can depend, not just national governance, but local governance, the ability to create jobs and opportunities for people who feel secure in those jobs are fundamentals that apply here and apply in Afghanistan. I'm actually encouraged based on the briefings that I¡¯ve received here, since I've been here, about the plans for the future." So it is apparent that senior military and political leaders are looking at Plan Colombia with regards to implementing aspects of this policy in Afghanistan and Pakistan. Therefore, Admiral Mullen continued by stating " .. there is great learning which has occurred for all of us—applying that learning to a place like Pakistan and Afghanistan is certainly part of the approach that I take in this review for that strategy." Admiral Mullen does state that many differences apply between both situations, for example geography, however, it is noticeable that many aspects of Plan Colombia do appear to appeal to him and other senior members of the military and Obama administration. However, some people question the effectiveness of Plan Colombia because of important human rights violations and the ongoing narcotic menace which is reaching the streets of so many nations. Therefore, Garry Leech, a senior writer for http://www.colombiajournal.org and a writer of many books, for example Beyond Bogotá: Diary of a Drug War Journalist in Colombia and The Failure of Global Capitalism: From Cape Breton to Colombia and Beyond, states a very different point of view about Plan Colombia. For according to Garry Leech, a much acclaimed journalist and writer and a free thinker, we must not ignore the negative aspects of Plan Colombia. Gary Leech states ¡°Not surprisingly, Mullen and others who advocate transferring the Plan Colombia model to Afghanistan point to improved security in Colombia's major population centers and a dramatic reduction in murders and kidnappings in recent years. While a significant percentage of the Colombian population has indeed benefited from these successes, Mullen and others conveniently ignore the humanitarian crisis that has resulted from this establishment of "security" and Plan Colombia's complete failure as a counter-narcotics initiative." Gary Leech continues by stating other valid points for he states that ¡° In recent decades, Colombia has endured one of the most under-reported humanitarian crises in the world ... With almost four million internal refugees, Colombia ranks second in the world after the Sudan. And while supporters of Plan Colombia repeatedly point to improved "security" in urban areas, critics note that the internal refugee crisis has worsened in recent years, in part because of the Colombian military¡¯s aggressive counter-insurgency tactics in rural regions." Therefore, it is abundantly clear that many aspects of Plan Colombia have failed and many people in Colombia have been uprooted, killed, or kidnapped. For example you had more than one thousand disappearances in 2008 in Colombia and clearly the motives are political and undemocratic. Also, many extrajudicial executions have taken place throughout this nation and the counter-narcotics initiative appears to have failed because cocaine production is still on the increase. Overall, I believe that you can not overlook the huge differences between Colombia and the crisis in Afghanistan and Pakistan. This applies to political ideology and religious ideology, and different military tactics which are used by FARC and radical Sunni Islamists. Other factors, for example terrain, motivation, suicide attacks, centralized structures via decentralized structures, and other important factors must not be ignored. More important, like Gary Leech points out, you have many failings within Plan Colombia and you also have many human rights violations. Therefore, if the Obama administration and senior military leaders want to focus on Plan Colombia, they must also look at the terrible consequences of this operation. More importantly, Obama hinted at ¡°a new history¡± for mankind but surely to focus on Plan Colombia then this is not ¡°a new history¡± but merely a continuing policy of mass intervention and the violation of rights.
Related Articles Myanmar, Bangladesh Sign an Accord but ... Japan Hopes to Boost Ties with Myanmar Drugs Crisis in Iran Emanating from Afghanistan Mexico Resembles a Civil War: Three Murders ... "Door Remains Open," French President Says President Trump and Ousted FBI Chief Comey: ... Moon Jae-in to Become President of South ... America, China, Russia Should Work Together on ... The Fading Spirit of Kano Chikanobu Awakened ... Japanese Poetry of Kakinomoto no Hitomaro: ... Trump Offers China Economic Inducements If ... Syria & Khan al-Assal Massacre: Western ... United States Botanic Garden and Stunning Art ... Syria: FSA and Al-Qaeda in Power Struggle Syria and the Sponsored Revolution Costing ... South Korean Fashion and Kpopsicle: Summer ... Syria and Shia Massacred by al-Nusra: Gulf and ... Turkey & Discontent towards Premier Erdogan: ... UK, MI5 and Syria: Hypocrites, Somalia and ... Christian Clergy in Syria Held Hostage by the ... China and Japan Play Cat and Mouse over ... Cameroon and Nigeria: French Hostages Released ... Alyse Radenovic, Bratunac and Srebrenica: Art ... Japanese Art and Bunjinga: Tani Buncho, Power ... Italian Fashion and Simonetta Sala: Adorable ... France, UK Want to Send Military Arms Directly ... Political Crisis in Tunisia after Belaid ... World of Art: Yuzo Saeki and Alyse Radenovic ... Nuclear Test by North Korea and Need for a ... Israel Violates the Sovereignty of Syria Egypt, Muslim Brotherhood: President Mursi ... Japan Art: Erotic Art, Sexuality and ... Algeria Hostage Crisis: Japan Needs to ... Syria and Bashar al-Assad Addresses Powerful ... US, France, UK Support Islamism LDP Wins Election in Japan FSA Islamists in Syria threaten to kill ... Syria Needs Support to Defend Itself against ... Egypt, Jordan and Turkey: Political Crisis and ... Japanese Art, Culture and the Yamabushi: ... Israel, Gaza and Doha: The Sham of the Western ... Syria & New Charade: Gulf Nations Should ... Tokyo Fashion and the Exquisite Boutique ... Sudan, South Sudan Crisis & Int'l Community Claude Monet Was Smitten by Japanese Art: ... Japan Tourism and Fukushima: Abukuma Cave, ... Japanese Art and Saburosuke Okada: the Power ... Japanese Art and Tosa School: Tosa Mitsunobu ... Syria and Terrorist Threat from Opposition: ... Russian Federation Lambasts Anti-Syria ... Syria: Outsiders Support Terrorism and US & ... Japanese Art and Bunjinga (Nanga): the ... Ontoshiki Is a Stunning Photographer in Tokyo: ... Japanese Art and Van Gogh: Japonisme, Ukiyo-e ... Associated Press Opens a Bureau in Pyongyang Fashion in South Korea: Kpopsicle & the trends ... Japanese Buddhist Art at the National Museum ... Japanese tourism: Jigokudani Monkey Park in ... South Korean Fashion: Kpopsicle, International ... BoA Releases Stunning New Song "Milestone" K-Pop and New Mini-Album Called "Snow Pink" by ... La Carmina and Tokyo: Alternative Fashion, ... K-Pop and T-ara in Japan: Stylish, Energetic ... Kanstyle Magazine to Open Up South Korean ... Tokyo Fashion: Jiyugoaka Is Trendy and a Great ... Korean Pop Music Continues to Hit Heights
in ... Yoshihiko Noda to Become New Prime Minister of ... Japan and the Political Farce: The Race Is On ... Tokyo tourism: Mount Takao-san Is a Stunning ... Ryo Ishikawa: Near to Making a Breakthrough at ... Lindsay Ann Hawker: Verdict Is Life in Prison ... Hokusai & Hakone: Ukiyo-e & Stunning Scenery Lindsay Ann Hawker: Does the Joji Obara/ Kim ... Burma (Myanmar): Free Burma Rangers update Japan & Child Abduction: Interview with Sonia ... Novak Djokovic Beats Rafael Nadal to Claim ... Kawanabe Kyosai: the Underworld and the ... Tatsuya Ichihashi Admits to Killing Lindsay ... Utagawa Kuniyoshi: Tranquil Art and Natural ... Southern Thailand and Islamization Islamic Terrorism: Afghanistan to Bosnia and ... IslamicJihad within the Territory of Russia Muslims Burn a Christian Alive in Pakistan Radical Islam and Terrorism in the Balkans Pakistan and Ongoing Christian Persecution Turkey Is Trying to Dictate to Armenia Bosnia and Clinton's Radical Islamists Iraq's Jewish Identity Faces Extinction Muslims Slaughter Christians in Egypt Somalia and the Reality of Radical Islam Racist Ishihara Fails to Get 2016 Olympic Games Daily Life in Japan and Isolation USA and the Internal Islamic Threat Indonesia and Ba¡¯asyir, the Preacher of Hate Nigeria and Christian Martyrs Indonesia and Islamic Terrorism Aceh in Indonesia Passes Stoning to Death Law 2016 Olympic Bid and Racist Governor of Tokyo Randy Collins and Child Abduction in Japan Islamic Militants Target Buddhists in Thailand Bangladesh Destroys Hinduism, Buddhism Child Abduction in Japan: Shane Clarke Case Islamic Ramadan Begins, Blood Keeps Flowing Kosovo and Ongoing De-Christianization USA Appeases Islam under President Obama Somalia, UK, and Killing of Christians Buddhists Fear to Walk in Southern Thailand Pakistan Must Abolish the Blasphemy Law Pakistan and Burning Alive of Christians Nigeria Challenged by Radical Islamists Somalia and Christian Martyrs Killed by Muslims KOSOVO & Systematic Persecution by KLA Japan Ignores Child Abduction because of Racism Japan Allows International Child Abduction Ethiopia Continues to Develop under EPRDF Saudi Arabia and Why Child Marriage Is Allowed China Faces a Fresh Bout of Ethnic Hatred Islam and the Myths of Unity and Peace IRAN Enters a Political Minefield alongside ... Islam Needs to Be Challenged by True Democracy North Korea's Point of View Myanmar: Ethnic Minorities & Aung San Suu Kyi Colombia and Extrajudicial Killings Scandal IRAQ and the Destruction of the Mandaean ... Non-Arabs of the Middle East and Persecution USA Is Worried about Events in Pakistan USA, CIA Created Sunni Islamic Terrorism Pakistan Faces Internal Threat N. Korea Pulls Out of 6-Party Talks because of ... Japan under Ishihara Must Not Be Given the ... MYANMAR – Karen Christians Face Joint ... Bolivia under Morales and the Indigenous Issue Mexico -- Drug Cartels and the American Market Saudi Arabia Allowing 8 Year Old Girls to ... USA -- Bail Outs Must Be Questioned after AIG ... Ethiopia under Prime Minister Meles Zenawi Europe Is Facing a Real Economic and Social ... USA is Deeply Concerned about Pakistan and ... USA -- Obama Is in Free Fall at the Moment Japan Must Not Be Rewarded the 2016 Olympics ... China, Russia Rebuke America at World Economic ... PAKISTAN -- Radical Sunni Islamists Are Now ... EU Is Alarmed by Gas Dispute between Russia ... USA -- Obama Faces Major Internal and External ... Zimbabwe Now Faces Cholera Epidemic alongside ... Pakistan and the Persecution of Ahmadiyya ... USA -- President Bush Is Trying to Contain ... India Becomes Yet Another Major Victim of ... Japan Needs to Create an Independent Foreign ... Mongolia and The Importance of This Nation to ... Islamic Radicals Support Stoning Women, ... Inflation Threatens to Engulf Vietnam and The ... Turkey and The Secular Card, Myth or Reality? Ethiopian Ambassador to Japan and Third ... SOUTH AFRICA, Race Attacks and Underlying ... EGYPT -- Coptic Christians Are Still ... Ethiopia Needs International Support to ... Armenia and Azerbaijan Are Still in Dispute ... Kosovo and the Crisis of Ignoring ... The UN Is Undemocratic and Manipulated, So ... America Is Seeking to Contain the Russian ... Iran Is a Stabilizing Power in Afghanistan and ... Venezuela -- Chavez the Enigma, a Great or ... Lebanon Needs to Dismantle the Armed Forces of ... Iraq and Destruction of Christianity since ... Bolivia Is Facing Meltdown So Can a Solution ... Macedonia Could Become the Next Balkan ... Russia Faces Many Security Concerns State Intervention Versus Globalization and ... Ethiopia and Its War against Radical Islam and ... PM Fukuda of Japan Resigns and This Nation Is ... Japan Needs Stability in a Time of Urgency Russia Responds to America's Intimidation Russian Federation & Next Stage of Development ... Market Confidence Remains Extremely Mixed Why China Needs to Modernize Her Armed Forces MEXICO -- President Calderon Is in a Flux ... Iran and America, Friends or Foe Georgia Took a Huge Gamble in South Ossetia ... Japan and the Suicide Problem Zimbabwe: Can Morgan Tsvangirai, Arthur ...
Lee Jay Walker serves as Tokyo Correspondent of The Seoul Times. He specializes in int'l relations and geopolitics. He is also involved in analyst work and research on business. After finishing BA degree in East European Studies at the University of London, He earned MA degree in Asia Pacific Studies in Nottingham Trent University. He also studied business at London Institute.
back
|
|
|
|
|